Mid-size Lux Sedans

[chevyguy06]

Note:On the Volvos I didn't know which one fit better so I lumped them into one.

[TheIntrepid]

I would take the one I'm buying.

[TBR]

Right now the A4, once the second gen CTS hits the streets my opinion might change.

[ro51092]

You guys already know.

Followed by the machine in my garage.

[TBR]

I would take the one I'm buying.

So a 3-series or C-class?

[TheIntrepid]

So a 3-series or C-class?

I thought you knew. My dad wants me to take a look at some corporate insider deals but it's most likely going to be a 335i sedan.

[chevyguy06]

I went with the 08' CTS-V

[mazda6er]

I think I'd probably take the Saab, actually. It's a hard choice though. My pick for this category changes a lot.

[TBR]

I went with the 08' CTS-V

So you voted for a car that we know nothing about?

[Raza]

Tough decision on this one.  Not much here I'd want to buy.

[mazda6er]

So you voted for a car that we know nothing about?

Well if you wanna get picky, half of these are compacts, too.  :P

[TBR]

I think I'd probably take the Saab, actually. It's a hard choice though. My pick for this category changes a lot.

The 9-3 is on my own short list, they depreciate rather rapidly (make that very, very rapidly).

[ro51092]

Tough decision on this one.  Not much here I'd want to buy.

You were just orgasming over the C-Class a few days ago.

[Raza]

You were just orgasming over the C-Class a few days ago.

Used is different than new.  New, I probably wouldn't buy any of them.

[Hev]

335i sedan, black on black, sports package, w/6speed manual

[565]

Infiniti G35.

[850CSi]

Wait, since when were any of these cars "Mid-Size Lux Sedans"?

I voted 3er because it's the best car on the list, although the E-Klasse happens to be the best 'Mid-Size Luxury Sedan'.

[cawimmer430]

The new C-Class. 

[chevyguy06]

I consider them "Mid-size" simply because they're bigger than the compact Caddy BLS for example. I guess the STS,5-series etc. would actually be considered "Midsized"

[850CSi]

I consider them "Mid-size" simply because they're bigger than the compact Caddy BLS for example. I guess the STS,5-series etc. would actually be considered "Midsized"

The BLS is based on the 9-3, it isn't significantly smaller than any of these cars; they're all classified as compact (although that is stretching it nowadays, but they're certainly not mid-size).

[chevyguy06]

So you voted for a car that we know nothing about?

I still would've voted for the 07' too, so it doesn't really matter.

[chevyguy06]

The BLS is based on the 9-3, it isn't significantly smaller than any of these cars; they're all classified as compact (although that is stretching it nowadays, but they're certainly not mid-size).

I just compared the interior volume of the mid-size Camry to the 3-series and most of the measurements are about the same.

[Raghavan]

335 for me.

[850CSi]

I just compared the interior volume of the mid-size Camry to the 3-series and most of the measurements are about the same.

Irrelevant because the Camry is a good 10 inches longer (it's bigger in every exterior dimension).

The 3-Series is classified as a compact sedan.

[Raza]

I guess I'm going to have to go A4/S4.  New, those are pretty much the only ones I'd buy.

[thewizard16]

A4/S4. I might give the new C and IS a look too, but I think that's probably what I'd end up with if I were shopping.

[chevyguy06]

It doesn't matter what they're called just pick your favorite.

[1 BAD 7]

A BMW 335i for me

[Champ]

Probably the S60 R if you'll let me choose that, if not probably the 335.

This is rather a vague question, and even though "Price is no object," it's a rather large price swing for some of these cars which makes it a loaded question in favor of the 335 almost every time.

[chevyguy06]

The S60R could've been chosen...I lumped the other high performance versions together, why not the Volvo?