CarSPIN Forums

Auto Talk => Luxury Talk => Topic started by: Fire It Up on May 12, 2005, 08:40:54 PM

Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: Fire It Up on May 12, 2005, 08:40:54 PM
Link (http://www.caranddriver.com/article.asp?section_id=3&article_id=9479)
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: MaxPower on May 12, 2005, 09:38:08 PM
It's a cool car and considering it's price of $40,000 I think we'll see plenty of them.  

Like Road & Track said, "a decidedly American Hemi heart with a European feel and sophistication to its driving dynamics.  Think of the SRT-8 as an American E55, with a savings of about $30 grand." (March 2005)

I think it's pretty neat.
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: ifcar on May 13, 2005, 05:18:00 AM
QuoteIt's a cool car and considering it's price of $40,000 I think we'll see plenty of them.  

Like Road & Track said, "a decidedly American Hemi heart with a European feel and sophistication to its driving dynamics.  Think of the SRT-8 as an American E55, with a savings of about $30 grand." (March 2005)

I think it's pretty neat.
I don't think they're making too many of them, even if they would sell.  
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: SJ_GTI on May 13, 2005, 08:11:49 AM
It sounds like a nice car, but I don't like that its automatic only.

I also think that these reviewers are getting progressively lazier and/or older or something. 5 years ago no way would some say that a manual transmission is not right for this type of car (too much effort?!? pfft!).  :angry:

Anyway, I would save my money and get the 400 HP GTO, with a 6-speed manual. If I absolutely needed a sedan I would just pony up the extra 8k for an S4 or CTS-V.
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: mazda6er on May 13, 2005, 09:13:02 AM
QuoteIt sounds like a nice car, but I don't like that its automatic only.

I also think that these reviewers are getting progressively lazier and/or older or something. 5 years ago no way would some say that a manual transmission is not right for this type of car (too much effort?!? pfft!).  :angry:

Anyway, I would save my money and get the 400 HP GTO, with a 6-speed manual. If I absolutely needed a sedan I would just pony up the extra 8k for an S4 or CTS-V.
I think you'd need more like an extra 18K.
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: SJ_GTI on May 13, 2005, 09:38:16 AM
Quote
QuoteIt sounds like a nice car, but I don't like that its automatic only.

I also think that these reviewers are getting progressively lazier and/or older or something. 5 years ago no way would some say that a manual transmission is not right for this type of car (too much effort?!? pfft!).? :angry:

Anyway, I would save my money and get the 400 HP GTO, with a 6-speed manual. If I absolutely needed a sedan I would just pony up the extra 8k for an S4 or CTS-V.
I think you'd need more like an extra 18K.
Price on the SRT-8 is 42k, the S4 starts at 46k, and the CTS-V starts 50k.

I am not saying the SRT-8 isn't a good deal, but if you want a 6MT its worth it to move up to one of these cars to me.
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: mazda6er on May 13, 2005, 09:41:15 AM
Quote
Quote
QuoteIt sounds like a nice car, but I don't like that its automatic only.

I also think that these reviewers are getting progressively lazier and/or older or something. 5 years ago no way would some say that a manual transmission is not right for this type of car (too much effort?!? pfft!).  :angry:

Anyway, I would save my money and get the 400 HP GTO, with a 6-speed manual. If I absolutely needed a sedan I would just pony up the extra 8k for an S4 or CTS-V.
I think you'd need more like an extra 18K.
Price on the SRT-8 is 42k, the S4 starts at 46k, and the CTS-V starts 50k.

I am not saying the SRT-8 isn't a good deal, but if you want a 6MT its worth it to move up to one of these cars to me.
Oh, my bad, I thought you were saying move up 8K from the GTO!  That's what I get for reading too quickly. My mistake.  :D
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: SJ_GTI on May 13, 2005, 09:50:09 AM
Quote
Quote
Quote
QuoteIt sounds like a nice car, but I don't like that its automatic only.

I also think that these reviewers are getting progressively lazier and/or older or something. 5 years ago no way would some say that a manual transmission is not right for this type of car (too much effort?!? pfft!).? :angry:

Anyway, I would save my money and get the 400 HP GTO, with a 6-speed manual. If I absolutely needed a sedan I would just pony up the extra 8k for an S4 or CTS-V.
I think you'd need more like an extra 18K.
Price on the SRT-8 is 42k, the S4 starts at 46k, and the CTS-V starts 50k.

I am not saying the SRT-8 isn't a good deal, but if you want a 6MT its worth it to move up to one of these cars to me.
Oh, my bad, I thought you were saying move up 8K from the GTO!  That's what I get for reading too quickly. My mistake.  :D
Ah okay. Like I said the GTO would be my first choice of course. I only mentioned the S4 and CTS-V as potentials if I absolutely needed 4 doors for some reason. So I meant to compare the STR-8 to those on price, since the GTO beats them all (handily).

Sorry for the confusion.
Title: CarandDriver Tests 300C SRT8
Post by: BMWDave on May 13, 2005, 12:36:02 PM
Quote
QuoteIt's a cool car and considering it's price of $40,000 I think we'll see plenty of them. 

Like Road & Track said, "a decidedly American Hemi heart with a European feel and sophistication to its driving dynamics.  Think of the SRT-8 as an American E55, with a savings of about $30 grand." (March 2005)

I think it's pretty neat.
I don't think they're making too many of them, even if they would sell.
I think they are making about 8K a year.