CarSPIN Forums

Auto Talk => The Mainstream Room => Topic started by: TBR on June 06, 2005, 08:50:35 PM

Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 06, 2005, 08:50:35 PM
Just wondering, I really think it looks good on the outside, though I am not quite so sure about the interior. It sounds like they have really invested big bucks to modernize their production techniques which should result in a lower curb weight than their previous cars had. The engine also has decent hp/liter, though it still isn't up there with Honda.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: Run Away on June 06, 2005, 09:04:00 PM
I think I saw a pic of it on the back of a Mcleans...245hp V6 right?

Really really sharp looking!
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: BMWDave on June 06, 2005, 09:04:19 PM
Its a great effort, and they now can compete with Japanese carmakers...they have much more to offer now than their warranty.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 06, 2005, 09:05:08 PM
QuoteI think I saw a pic of it on the back of a Mcleans...245hp V6 right?

Really really sharp looking!
235 hp. It is an extremely good looking car, the best looking mainstream sedan imho.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: BMWDave on June 06, 2005, 09:06:10 PM
Quote
QuoteI think I saw a pic of it on the back of a Mcleans...245hp V6 right?

Really really sharp looking!
235 hp. It is an extremely good looking car, the best looking mainstream sedan imho.
I think it ranks high as the best looking, although I see too much Honda in the back.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 06, 2005, 09:12:46 PM
Quote
Quote
QuoteI think I saw a pic of it on the back of a Mcleans...245hp V6 right?

Really really sharp looking!
235 hp. It is an extremely good looking car, the best looking mainstream sedan imho.
I think it ranks high as the best looking, although I see too much Honda in the back.
I can definitely see that, but they did a much better job with it than Honda did and it isn't like it is a design trait Honda uses in all of their cars.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: BMWDave on June 06, 2005, 09:13:50 PM
Quote
Quote
Quote
QuoteI think I saw a pic of it on the back of a Mcleans...245hp V6 right?

Really really sharp looking!
235 hp. It is an extremely good looking car, the best looking mainstream sedan imho.
I think it ranks high as the best looking, although I see too much Honda in the back.
I can definitely see that, but they did a much better job with it than Honda did and it isn't like it is a design trait Honda uses in all of their cars.
True...the Honda looks frumpy and fussy, while the Hyundais end looks a lot better.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: Laconian on June 07, 2005, 02:18:12 AM
Here's hoping that engine will trickle into the rest of Hyundai's lineup soon.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: Secret Chimp on June 07, 2005, 02:48:19 AM
It's not the kind of car I'd buy, but at last Hyundai is becoming a respectable brand (and how quickly as of late, might I add)
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 07, 2005, 05:55:42 AM
If it's as good as it looks, it's best-in-class: basically an Accord for $2k less.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: Lorinser on June 07, 2005, 05:26:52 PM
I really like it, and I hope that it will be better than the CamCord duo.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: BMWDave on June 07, 2005, 05:29:53 PM
QuoteI really like it, and I hope that it will be better than the CamCord duo.
I'm sure it will hold its own quite well, and may even beat them.  Its V6 is stronger than the Camrys, and almost on par with an Accord.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 07, 2005, 05:33:23 PM
Quote
QuoteI really like it, and I hope that it will be better than the CamCord duo.
I'm sure it will hold its own quite well, and may even beat them.  Its V6 is stronger than the Camrys, and almost on par with an Accord.
And it is still considerably cheaper.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: BMWDave on June 07, 2005, 05:36:52 PM
Quote
Quote
QuoteI really like it, and I hope that it will be better than the CamCord duo.
I'm sure it will hold its own quite well, and may even beat them.  Its V6 is stronger than the Camrys, and almost on par with an Accord.
And it is still considerably cheaper.
That is another amazing thing going for it.  And I'm sure it has a better warranty too.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 07, 2005, 05:38:17 PM
Quote
Quote
Quote
QuoteI really like it, and I hope that it will be better than the CamCord duo.
I'm sure it will hold its own quite well, and may even beat them.  Its V6 is stronger than the Camrys, and almost on par with an Accord.
And it is still considerably cheaper.
That is another amazing thing going for it.  And I'm sure it has a better warranty too.
Without doubt.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: GMPenguin on June 07, 2005, 05:46:56 PM
QuoteJust wondering, I really think it looks good on the outside, though I am not quite so sure about the interior. It sounds like they have really invested big bucks to modernize their production techniques which should result in a lower curb weight than their previous cars had. The engine also has decent hp/liter, though it still isn't up there with Honda.
You said it all better than I could've. :praise:  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 07, 2005, 06:38:30 PM
Quote
QuoteJust wondering, I really think it looks good on the outside, though I am not quite so sure about the interior. It sounds like they have really invested big bucks to modernize their production techniques which should result in a lower curb weight than their previous cars had. The engine also has decent hp/liter, though it still isn't up there with Honda.
You said it all better than I could've. :praise:
Why are we not surprised?  <_<  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 07, 2005, 06:41:19 PM
Quote
Quote
QuoteJust wondering, I really think it looks good on the outside, though I am not quite so sure about the interior. It sounds like they have really invested big bucks to modernize their production techniques which should result in a lower curb weight than their previous cars had. The engine also has decent hp/liter, though it still isn't up there with Honda.
You said it all better than I could've. :praise:
Why are we not surprised?  <_<
Really, why would you be? I am more intelligent than all of the rest of you combined. ;)  :lol:  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 07, 2005, 06:56:34 PM
Quote
Quote
Quote
QuoteJust wondering, I really think it looks good on the outside, though I am not quite so sure about the interior. It sounds like they have really invested big bucks to modernize their production techniques which should result in a lower curb weight than their previous cars had. The engine also has decent hp/liter, though it still isn't up there with Honda.
You said it all better than I could've. :praise:
Why are we not surprised?  <_<
Really, why would you be? I am more intelligent than all of the rest of you combined. ;)  :lol:
<_<  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: 93JC on June 09, 2005, 06:10:49 PM
I hope it sells well for Hyundai. In fact, I hope it outsells the Accord and Camry put together.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 09, 2005, 06:15:00 PM
QuoteI hope it sells well for Hyundai. In fact, I hope it outsells the Accord and Camry put together.
I think it just might have a chance of keeping up with them, the reviews have been great, it looks great, and it is priced great.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 05:58:57 AM
But it's still a Hyundai, and the Accord and Camry are still the Accord and Camry. All three cars have reputations that will do as much for their sales as their actual merits and demerits will.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 10:12:19 AM
QuoteBut it's still a Hyundai, and the Accord and Camry are still the Accord and Camry. All three cars have reputations that will do as much for their sales as their actual merits and demerits will.
The Accord and Camry might have better reputations, but the Sonata has price and warranty advantages on its side.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 10:16:12 AM
And reputations matter. I certainly wouldn't expect to see the Sonata match the Accord in sales, nor do I expect to see a marked decline in either Accord or Camry sales. It's the lower-end midsizes that compete more in price than performance that will suffer the most.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 10:28:33 AM
QuoteAnd reputations matter. I certainly wouldn't expect to see the Sonata match the Accord in sales, nor do I expect to see a marked decline in either Accord or Camry sales. It's the lower-end midsizes that compete more in price than performance that will suffer the most.
Reputation certainly matters, that is the only reason the Camry sells so well because in reality it is pretty much just a medicore product. However, price matters almost as much and I think a lot of people care less about reputation if you get a stellar warranty free of charge. The diehard Toyota and Honda fanatics won't be buying on anytime soon, but those that are so loyal very well might.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 10:36:24 AM
I don't doubt that the long price and warranty will bring in many consumers, but I don't think that so many of them will have chosen an Accord or Camry anyway that their sales will change very much.

And I disagree that the Camry is a mediocre product, as you may already know, but that's for a different thread.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 10:44:27 AM
QuoteI don't doubt that the long price and warranty will bring in many consumers, but I don't think that so many of them will have chosen an Accord or Camry anyway that their sales will change very much.

And I disagree that the Camry is a mediocre product, as you may already know, but that's for a different thread.
Yes, I know you do, but I personally don't see what it has over any of the competition in the area of refinement while almost all of its competition isn't as bland.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 11:01:58 AM
Quote
QuoteI don't doubt that the long price and warranty will bring in many consumers, but I don't think that so many of them will have chosen an Accord or Camry anyway that their sales will change very much.

And I disagree that the Camry is a mediocre product, as you may already know, but that's for a different thread.
Yes, I know you do, but I personally don't see what it has over any of the competition in the area of refinement while almost all of its competition isn't as bland.
And I don't consider blandness to be a flaw for a mainstream sedan. Besides, take any rather interesting sedan and sell 500,000 of them a year for five years, and you'd consider it to be bland as well.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 11:03:11 AM
Quote
Quote
QuoteI don't doubt that the long price and warranty will bring in many consumers, but I don't think that so many of them will have chosen an Accord or Camry anyway that their sales will change very much.

And I disagree that the Camry is a mediocre product, as you may already know, but that's for a different thread.
Yes, I know you do, but I personally don't see what it has over any of the competition in the area of refinement while almost all of its competition isn't as bland.
And I don't consider blandness to be a flaw for a mainstream sedan. Besides, take any rather interesting sedan and sell 500,000 of them a year for five years, and you'd consider it to be bland as well.
I don't consider it to be a flaw unless all of its competitors do everything as well with more excitement. Then it is a flaw and that is the case here imho.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 11:13:13 AM
Name one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 11:18:04 AM
QuoteName one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan.
Excitement. Name one aspect that is ahead of the others.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 11:26:49 AM
Quote
QuoteName one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan.
Excitement. Name one aspect that is ahead of the others.
How is a Camry less exciting than a Kia Optima? How is it less so than a Ford Taurus? Or a Chevy Malibu or Impala?

And answer me this: what one car beats the Camry in every way?
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 11:27:46 AM
Quote
Quote
QuoteName one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan.
Excitement. Name one aspect that is ahead of the others.
How is a Camry less exciting than a Kia Optima? How is it less so than a Ford Taurus? Or a Chevy Malibu or Impala?

And answer me this: what one car beats the Camry in every way?
Accord and Altima.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 11:35:47 AM
Quote
Quote
Quote
QuoteName one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan.
Excitement. Name one aspect that is ahead of the others.
How is a Camry less exciting than a Kia Optima? How is it less so than a Ford Taurus? Or a Chevy Malibu or Impala?

And answer me this: what one car beats the Camry in every way?
Accord and Altima.
Nope. The Camry has more trunk space than the Accord and Altima, did better in crash  testing than the Altima, has more rear seat room than the Accord, has a less-firm ride than the Altima (and more midsize sedan shoppers will be going after ride softness than ride firmness), has less road noise than either the Accord or Altima, and, depending on options, is even less expensive than the Altima.

And you only answered my second question.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: mazda6er on June 15, 2005, 11:42:18 AM
QuoteNope. The Camry has more trunk space than the Accord and Altima, did better in crash  testing than the Altima, has more rear seat room than the Accord, has a less-firm ride than the Altima (and more midsize sedan shoppers will be going after ride softness than ride firmness), has less road noise than either the Accord or Altima, and, depending on options, is even less expensive than the Altima.

And you only answered my second question.
I think the Impala may be more exciting than the Camry, but of those others you've listed, probably not. Although the Taurus is on its way out and the Malibu and Optima hardly matter in my mind. (The Optima will probably be redesigned based on the Sonata soon anyway).

I'd pit my Mazda against the Camry any day, but I may be a bit biased. The 6 beats it easily in handling, has comparable acceleration, is very safe, and has a high-quality and fairly roomy interior and trunk. The Camry ride is more refined, and it offers some "higher end" options, but it's hard to find any car that can beat every car at everything, no matter how polished it is.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 11:42:23 AM
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
QuoteName one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan.
Excitement. Name one aspect that is ahead of the others.
How is a Camry less exciting than a Kia Optima? How is it less so than a Ford Taurus? Or a Chevy Malibu or Impala?

And answer me this: what one car beats the Camry in every way?
Accord and Altima.
Nope. The Camry has more trunk space than the Accord and Altima, did better in crash  testing than the Altima, has more rear seat room than the Accord, has a less-firm ride than the Altima (and more midsize sedan shoppers will be going after ride softness than ride firmness), has less road noise than either the Accord or Altima, and, depending on options, is even less expensive than the Altima.

And you only answered my second question.
As far as I am concerned both cars' rear seats are as comfortable as the Camry's and trunk space is close for both of them. The Altima's ride might be a bit firmer but it is still very good imho and any road noise difference isn't noticable. And, if those arguments don't float with you (and I suspect they won't), what about the Five Hundred?

I didn't answer your second question because I never said that there weren't cars as boring or even more boring than the Camry.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 11:51:59 AM
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quote
QuoteName one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan.
Excitement. Name one aspect that is ahead of the others.
How is a Camry less exciting than a Kia Optima? How is it less so than a Ford Taurus? Or a Chevy Malibu or Impala?

And answer me this: what one car beats the Camry in every way?
Accord and Altima.
Nope. The Camry has more trunk space than the Accord and Altima, did better in crash  testing than the Altima, has more rear seat room than the Accord, has a less-firm ride than the Altima (and more midsize sedan shoppers will be going after ride softness than ride firmness), has less road noise than either the Accord or Altima, and, depending on options, is even less expensive than the Altima.

And you only answered my second question.
As far as I am concerned both cars' rear seats are as comfortable

Your concern doesn't modify fact.

as the Camry's and trunk space is close for both of them.

The Camry has 20% more trunk space than the Accord, and 7% more than the Altima.

The Altima's ride might be a bit firmer but it is still very good imho

I specifically said "better than the Camry in every way" not "about as good as the Camry".

and any road noise difference isn't noticable.

Wrong, especially on the 3.5SE.

And, if those arguments don't float with you (and I suspect they won't), what about the Five Hundred?

The Camry is quicker, quieter, and less expensive.

I didn't answer your second question because I never said that there weren't cars as boring or even more boring than the Camry.

Actually, you did. I asked you to "name one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan" and your reply was "excitement".
...
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 11:53:12 AM
Quote
QuoteNope. The Camry has more trunk space than the Accord and Altima, did better in crash  testing than the Altima, has more rear seat room than the Accord, has a less-firm ride than the Altima (and more midsize sedan shoppers will be going after ride softness than ride firmness), has less road noise than either the Accord or Altima, and, depending on options, is even less expensive than the Altima.

And you only answered my second question.
I think the Impala may be more exciting than the Camry, but of those others you've listed, probably not. Although the Taurus is on its way out and the Malibu and Optima hardly matter in my mind. (The Optima will probably be redesigned based on the Sonata soon anyway).

I'd pit my Mazda against the Camry any day, but I may be a bit biased. The 6 beats it easily in handling, has comparable acceleration, is very safe, and has a high-quality and fairly roomy interior and trunk. The Camry ride is more refined, and it offers some "higher end" options, but it's hard to find any car that can beat every car at everything, no matter how polished it is.
Nope, but except for very good cars, you can usually find one car to beat one car at everything.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 12:00:23 PM
As far as I am concerned both cars' rear seats are as comfortable
Your concern doesn't modify fact.
In the past on C/D you said that space is a matter of personal opinion, my opinion is that the difference is next to non existent

as the Camry's and trunk space is close for both of them.
The Camry has 20% more trunk space than the Accord, and 7% more than the Altima.
Floor space is similiar and in my opinion that is a much more important number than cubic footage

The Altima's ride might be a bit firmer but it is still very good imho
I specifically said "better than the Camry in every way" not "about as good as the Camry".
I never said that there were cars out there that were better than the Camry in every way, I said there were cars that were as good as the Camry in every way while offering more excitement

and any road noise difference isn't noticable.
Wrong, especially on the 3.5SE.
Opinions aren't wrong

And, if those arguments don't float with you (and I suspect they won't), what about the Five Hundred?
The Camry is quicker, quieter, and less expensive.
I'll agree with quicker (but only if you get the Camry Se-V6), but I won't comment on quieter because I have no experience in a Five Hundred on the road and as far as I am concerned your Toyota bias (and you do have one) makes your comments in situations like this useless. I will look at the prices later this afternoon, but I am pretty sure that the Five Hundred is comparably priced

I didn't answer your second question because I never said that there weren't cars as boring or even more boring than the Camry.
Actually, you did. I asked you to "name one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan" and your reply was "excitement".
Twisting my words around, are you? I never suggested that every midsize sedan was exciting, but I did suggest that there are quite a few that are more exciting.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 12:10:03 PM
QuoteAs far as I am concerned both cars' rear seats are as comfortable
Your concern doesn't modify fact.
In the past on C/D you said that space is a matter of personal opinion, my opinion is that the difference is next to non existent
Not space, comfort.

as the Camry's and trunk space is close for both of them.
The Camry has 20% more trunk space than the Accord, and 7% more than the Altima.
Floor space is similiar and in my opinion that is a much more important number than cubic footage
Do you have actual measurements to back that up with?

The Altima's ride might be a bit firmer but it is still very good imho
I specifically said "better than the Camry in every way" not "about as good as the Camry".
I never said that there were cars out there that were better than the Camry in every way, I said there were cars that were as good as the Camry in every way while offering more excitement
My post asked "what one car beats the Camry in every way?" Your answer was "Accord and Altima". Or am I "twisting your words" again?

and any road noise difference isn't noticable.
Wrong, especially on the 3.5SE.
Opinions aren't wrong

I noticed it.

And, if those arguments don't float with you (and I suspect they won't), what about the Five Hundred?
The Camry is quicker, quieter, and less expensive.
I'll agree with quicker (but only if you get the Camry Se-V6), but I won't comment on quieter because I have no experience in a Five Hundred on the road and as far as I am concerned your Toyota bias (and you do have one) makes your comments in situations like this useless. I will look at the prices later this afternoon, but I am pretty sure that the Five Hundred is comparably priced
I believe that even the standard V6 is quicker, but there aren't many sources that have actually measured times for both. And engine noise is definitely more prevelent on the Five Hundred during acceleration than in the Camry. And don't just throw out some sticker prices either, use either CarsDirect or TMV.

I didn't answer your second question because I never said that there weren't cars as boring or even more boring than the Camry.
Actually, you did. I asked you to "name one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan" and your reply was "excitement".
Twisting my words around, are you? I never suggested that every midsize sedan was exciting, but I did suggest that there are quite a few that are more exciting.
I told you what was in the post that you replied to, and what your reply was. Explain how I twisted your words.
...
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 12:15:31 PM
As far as I am concerned both cars' rear seats are as comfortable
Your concern doesn't modify fact.
In the past on C/D you said that space is a matter of personal opinion, my opinion is that the difference is next to non existent
Not space, comfort.
Sorry for the typo, comfort is even more subjective

as the Camry's and trunk space is close for both of them.
The Camry has 20% more trunk space than the Accord, and 7% more than the Altima.
Floor space is similiar and in my opinion that is a much more important number than cubic footage
Do you have actual measurements to back that up with?
Nope, just personal experience

The Altima's ride might be a bit firmer but it is still very good imho
I specifically said "better than the Camry in every way" not "about as good as the Camry".
I never said that there were cars out there that were better than the Camry in every way, I said there were cars that were as good as the Camry in every way while offering more excitement
My post asked "what one car beats the Camry in every way?" Your answer was "Accord and Altima". Or am I "twisting your words" again?
I admit that I didn't read that post very well, however, that question was completely out of context as I never suggested that there were cars that were better than the Camry in every way, just that there are cars out their that match in every way and add in more fun

and any road noise difference isn't noticable.
Wrong, especially on the 3.5SE.
Opinions aren't wrong
I noticed it.

And, if those arguments don't float with you (and I suspect they won't), what about the Five Hundred?
The Camry is quicker, quieter, and less expensive.
I'll agree with quicker (but only if you get the Camry Se-V6), but I won't comment on quieter because I have no experience in a Five Hundred on the road and as far as I am concerned your Toyota bias (and you do have one) makes your comments in situations like this useless. I will look at the prices later this afternoon, but I am pretty sure that the Five Hundred is comparably priced
I believe that even the standard V6 is quicker, but there aren't many sources that have actually measured times for both. And engine noise is definitely more prevelent on the Five Hundred during acceleration than in the Camry. And don't just throw out some sticker prices either, use either CarsDirect or TMV.
I will use TMV to compare the values, but not the prices

I didn't answer your second question because I never said that there weren't cars as boring or even more boring than the Camry.
Actually, you did. I asked you to "name one aspect of the Camry that is behind every other midsize sedan" and your reply was "excitement".
Twisting my words around, are you? I never suggested that every midsize sedan was exciting, but I did suggest that there are quite a few that are more exciting.
I told you what was in the post that you replied to, and what your reply was. Explain how I twisted your words.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 12:21:46 PM
To the trunk space: Personal experience in regards to measurements means exactly nothing. Unless you have actual floor space measurements, go by the volume measurement, in which the Altima loses and the Accord falls far short. BTW, in my personal non-measured experience, the Camry trunk has a lot more floor space than the Accord's.

To the comprehension issue: You still haven't provided an example of a car that matches the Camry in EVERY way.

To the pricing: This has become a simple matter of terminology. I'm not going to try and remember which terms I need to use to get the point across. You know what I mean. Just use Edmunds, and post both MSRP and TMV figures. It wouldn't take any longer, and would be more useful.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 12:27:52 PM
QuoteTo the trunk space: Personal experience in regards to measurements means exactly nothing. Unless you have actual floor space measurements, go by the volume measurement, in which the Altima loses and the Accord falls far short. BTW, in my personal non-measured experience, the Camry trunk has a lot more floor space than the Accord's.

To the comprehension issue: You still haven't provided an example of a car that matches the Camry in EVERY way.

To the pricing: This has become a simple matter of terminology. I'm not going to try and remember which terms I need to use to get the point across. You know what I mean. Just use Edmunds, and post both MSRP and TMV figures. It wouldn't take any longer, and would be more useful.
Volume measurements mean nothing to me.

The Accord matches the Camry in comfort, price, performance, and styling

MSRP is a cars price, TMV is a cars value. If you want to determine whether or not a car is overpriced you have to compare that car's msrp with its competitors or use the msrp in conjunction with the TMV. If you want to determine if a car is overvalued you compare its TMV with those of its competitors. Quite simple really, TMV stands for True Market Value while MSRP stands for Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 01:03:12 PM
Quote
QuoteTo the trunk space: Personal experience in regards to measurements means exactly nothing. Unless you have actual floor space measurements, go by the volume measurement, in which the Altima loses and the Accord falls far short. BTW, in my personal non-measured experience, the Camry trunk has a lot more floor space than the Accord's.

To the comprehension issue: You still haven't provided an example of a car that matches the Camry in EVERY way.

To the pricing: This has become a simple matter of terminology. I'm not going to try and remember which terms I need to use to get the point across. You know what I mean. Just use Edmunds, and post both MSRP and TMV figures. It wouldn't take any longer, and would be more useful.
Volume measurements mean nothing to me.
Non-existent measurements mean nothing to me.

The Accord matches the Camry in comfort, price, performance, and styling
It matches it in general areas, but falls short in several specific ones, which I pointed out earlier.

MSRP is a cars price, TMV is a cars value. If you want to determine whether or not a car is overpriced you have to compare that car's msrp with its competitors or use the msrp in conjunction with the TMV. If you want to determine if a car is overvalued you compare its TMV with those of its competitors. Quite simple really, TMV stands for True Market Value while MSRP stands for Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price
Only one matters to me, it would be the amount of money given to own the car. That's what's important, not the number on the window sticker.
...
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 01:05:42 PM
QuoteIt matches it in general areas, but falls short in several specific ones, which I pointed out earlier.
Trunk volume is the only one I can recall you mentioning.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 01:07:28 PM
Quote
QuoteIt matches it in general areas, but falls short in several specific ones, which I pointed out earlier.
Trunk volume is the only one I can recall you mentioning.
I mentioned others, but you discounted them by saying that you didn't think there was a significant difference. I still stand by them.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 01:09:58 PM
Quote
Quote
QuoteIt matches it in general areas, but falls short in several specific ones, which I pointed out earlier.
Trunk volume is the only one I can recall you mentioning.
I mentioned others, but you discounted them by saying that you didn't think there was a significant difference. I still stand by them.
Ah, I see, road noise and rear seat room where the other two. In my experience with the two cars (top trim levels in both cases and just about as back to back as I have ever ridden in two competing cars) the differences are neligible in both categories.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 01:17:40 PM
If you're talking about back seat comfort, that may very well be. If you're talking about actual space, you'd be wrong according to the dimensions provided by the manufacturers. link (http://www.edmunds.com/apps/nvc/edmunds/VehicleComparison;jsessionid=Cw2RXCmJ8yqybmC8NN1dmhqDQhTpPT9h1sbwvwnFGh7w1Gt2LP0Q!-90639216?styleid=100411903&styleid=100452083&maxvehicles=5&refid=&op=3&tab=specs)

The Camry beats it in every way, except for a tenth of an inch in headroom.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 01:32:09 PM
QuoteIf you're talking about back seat comfort, that may very well be. If you're talking about actual space, you'd be wrong according to the dimensions provided by the manufacturers. link (http://www.edmunds.com/apps/nvc/edmunds/VehicleComparison;jsessionid=Cw2RXCmJ8yqybmC8NN1dmhqDQhTpPT9h1sbwvwnFGh7w1Gt2LP0Q!-90639216?styleid=100411903&styleid=100452083&maxvehicles=5&refid=&op=3&tab=specs)

The Camry beats it in every way, except for a tenth of an inch in headroom.
Space doesn't matter as long as you are comfortable.  
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: ifcar on June 15, 2005, 01:52:11 PM
While I agree that a well-shaped seat is better than a roomy, misshapen seat, larger folks need both to be comfortable.
Title: The '06 Sonata
Post by: TBR on June 15, 2005, 01:54:23 PM
QuoteWhile I agree that a well-shaped seat is better than a roomy, misshapen seat, larger folks need both to be comfortable.
Fine, I will give you that one. If you constantly haul around more than one six foot tall person then the Camry is a better choice than the Accord.