CarSPIN Forums

Auto Talk => The Garage => Topic started by: JWC on May 16, 2005, 09:30:41 PM

Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 16, 2005, 09:30:41 PM
I was checking out the Ford forums today...kinda slow this afternoon at work and came across a discussion about 2005 Ford Focus air filters. A tech wanted to know where the darn thing was located. He found what he thought was the air filter box, but couldn't get into it. Turns out, it is now a sealed box with a non-replaceable, long life air filter.

Well, you can replace it, you just have to buy the whole air cleaner box, filter inside.  Starting at 250.00 for the basic Focus and ending at $350.00 for the performance engines.

I guess I've been spending too much time in the darkroom and not enough time following the auto market.  Has any other manufacturer lost their minds beside Ford?

This seems to be a pattern with Ford. Recently we had to replace the engine in a 2004 T-Bird because of what started out as an oil leak repair turned into a horror story. After we located the culprit gasket, we couldn't obtain the part. Ford won't sell it separate from the engine. It was under warranty, so Ford paid for the new engine. Same with the crankshaft. That's unavailable separately.  Ford will not sell certain repair parts for this engine....from what we understand it is to prevent certain repairs from being made on them.

No wonder this company is in trouble.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: 850CSi on May 17, 2005, 05:42:25 AM
That's ridiculous.


Imagine if European manufacturers did that...
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: crv16 on May 17, 2005, 06:14:03 AM
Well, they can't make money selling cars, so now they resort to tactics like this.

The dealers are probably asking for stuff like this, don't you think?  Modern cars require a fraction of the maintenance they did in years past, which in turn reduces the income stream for dealers.

Look at my Civic.  It calls for oil & filter changes (every 10k! miles), $12 air filter changes every 30k, $25 cabin air filters every 30k and radiator flush every 60k.  The only real maintenance comes at 110k, where the plugs, timing belt, tranny oil get changed.

I do all this crap myself, and it will likely cost under $400 in maintenance to get this car to 100k.  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 17, 2005, 05:37:06 PM
From a dealer viewpoint, we're not very happy. Who wants to be the first to tell a Focus owner that he needs and air filter and that it is hundreds of dollars?  It didn't seem to go over well on the FMC board.

There is some speculation that it is a 100K filter or that is may be covered 100K, but that hasn't been verified.   Regardless, speaking to a tech we brought over from a larger dealer, he was given the job of "checking" the air filter on a 15K mile used Focus. He ended up removing the front wheel and the bumper to access the box. Though he couldn't get the box open completely, he did get a peek inside. It was full of dust, leaves, and pine straw.  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: Catman on May 17, 2005, 05:43:13 PM
So there's no easy access at all?  Does aftermarket make a replacement?  It's an airfilter, there's no such thing as 100K life.  A few miles in real dusty conditions would take its toll.  If it does last 100K than that sucker isn't breathing too well. :rolleyes:  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 17, 2005, 05:50:12 PM
According to the only tech I know who has taken one out....no, there isn't any easy access.

This is a fine way to screw up a car that finally has become reliable.  Since the 2001my, there hasn't been anything major go wrong with them. Matter of fact, we were talking about that at the shop not long ago. We're seeing them with over 120k miles on them now and no engine or transmission problems.  Even the interiors are holding up pretty well at the mileage.

I said today at work, if I find myself with one, I'm going to find a way to adapt a air filter box from an older model onto the 2005.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: Catman on May 17, 2005, 06:07:42 PM
QuoteAccording to the only tech I know who has taken one out....no, there isn't any easy access.

This is a fine way to screw up a car that finally has become reliable.  Since the 2001my, there hasn't been anything major go wrong with them. Matter of fact, we were talking about that at the shop not long ago. We're seeing them with over 120k miles on them now and no engine or transmission problems.  Even the interiors are holding up pretty well at the mileage.

I said today at work, if I find myself with one, I'm going to find a way to adapt a air filter box from an older model onto the 2005.
I think they're a great little car and the new interior isn't bad at all.  What's a sedan going for right now?  Can you get one for $12,000?
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 17, 2005, 06:12:15 PM
Honestly, I'm not sure what is the current MSRP. I'm on the service desk. I can tell you that it is currently 25.23 for an oil change. :D  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: Catman on May 17, 2005, 06:19:31 PM
QuoteHonestly, I'm not sure what is the current MSRP. I'm on the service desk. I can tell you that it is currently 25.23 for an oil change. :D
LOL, just checked Edmunds.  Looks like about $14K with some good options including the $2000 rebate.  That's not bad.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 17, 2005, 06:24:44 PM
You know, after working for so many new car dealers, it is difficult to get excited about even a new model.  When I first started working at dealerships, I spent all my time on the lot looking and thinking "yeah, that'd be nice to own".

Now, they just look like more work. :D  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: Lebowski on May 17, 2005, 08:13:03 PM
That's unbelievable.  That doesn't make any sense.  Is there any way to clean it?  I.E., even with a "permanent" filter like a k&n, you still have to take it out and clean it every so often.  Like said before, a filter by definition isn't really permanent, eventually it's going to get gunked up and need to be cleaned or replaced.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 17, 2005, 08:23:56 PM
QuoteThat's unbelievable.  That doesn't make any sense.  Is there any way to clean it?  I.E., even with a "permanent" filter like a k&n, you still have to take it out and clean it every so often.  Like said before, a filter by definition isn't really permanent, eventually it's going to get gunked up and need to be cleaned or replaced.
Evidently not.....its a sealed air box with the filter inside. The tech we talked to today said he only opened enough to peek inside.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 17, 2005, 08:27:14 PM
The ironic part of working at the Ford dealer is everyone, especially the techs, rags on me for owning a Saab. I usually hear comments like "you'll "Saab" when you have to buy any parts" or "Saabs are too expensive to work on".

So far, I've haven't seen where Saab parts are any more expensive than Ford and the realiability seems to be the same. Granted, my 2001 9-5 only has 19k on the odometer, but....my air filter only runs 25.00.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: VTEC_Inside on May 17, 2005, 10:29:52 PM
I don't think it will be long till someone makes an aftermarket "stock" filter box.

That really does seem kinda stupid.

Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: The Phantom on May 18, 2005, 12:21:51 PM
QuoteSo there's no easy access at all?  Does aftermarket make a replacement?  It's an airfilter, there's no such thing as 100K life.  A few miles in real dusty conditions would take its toll.  If it does last 100K than that sucker isn't breathing too well. :rolleyes:
You know, just last week, I dropped a K&N filter into my air box.  Upon inspection of the old filter, after 20k miles, it was really clean.  And, I think you know, the Central Valley is a very dusty area.

Anyway, I would hope that if the air filter caused a problem, it would be covered under warranty, especially since it isn't something that's replaceable by the consumer.  Gosh, Ford seems to be treating the Focus like something it isn't--a cool car.  :P
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: The Phantom on May 18, 2005, 12:29:48 PM
QuoteThe ironic part of working at the Ford dealer is everyone, especially the techs, rags on me for owning a Saab. I usually hear comments like "you'll "Saab" when you have to buy any parts" or "Saabs are too expensive to work on".

So far, I've haven't seen where Saab parts are any more expensive than Ford and the realiability seems to be the same. Granted, my 2001 9-5 only has 19k on the odometer, but....my air filter only runs 25.00.
One of the things my dad always told me was that foreign cars these days are more expensive to maintain.

I found that to be false with the Acura.  Of course, being FWD, anything going wrong with the front probably would cost more, but no more than the Grand Am would cost.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: SargeMonkey on May 18, 2005, 01:38:56 PM
Acura is not import. But $250 for a filter, whoa :o  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: The Phantom on May 18, 2005, 02:01:07 PM
QuoteAcura is not import. But $250 for a filter, whoa :o
If that's the case, then neither is Saab.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: SargeMonkey on May 18, 2005, 08:52:58 PM
Nope saab = Gm, Acura = Acura?  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: VTEC_Inside on May 19, 2005, 10:27:59 PM
QuoteNope saab = Gm, Acura = Acura?
You might want to do a little more research.

I don't know about the Saab, but all RSXs are built in Japan and imported.

To be clear Acura acutally = Honda.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: hahn on May 20, 2005, 11:02:43 AM
Quote
QuoteNope saab = Gm, Acura = Acura?
You might want to do a little more research.

I don't know about the Saab, but all RSXs are built in Japan and imported.

To be clear Acura acutally = Honda.
Even though Saab is now part of the GM empire, all Saabs are still built in Sweden, for the time being anyway.  I believe that Saab's main factory is in Trollhattan.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: The Phantom on May 20, 2005, 01:14:22 PM
Right.  The Acura RSX is built in Japan and is called the Honda Integra over there.  I believe the TL is built over here, as is the MDX.  The RL is built in Japan and is the Honda Legend over there.  The TSX is the Honda Accord over there.  I believe that may actually be built in Great Britain, but I'm not absolutely sure.  Then, of course, there's the NSX, which is built in Japan.

The Honda Accord, which is built over here, is the Honda Inspire in Japan.  The MDX is sold in Japan as the MDX, but I don't think the TL is sold over there any more.  It used to be the Inspire and Saber, but now the American Accord has the Inspire name.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: Run Away on May 20, 2005, 01:44:48 PM
MDX/Odessey/Civic are build in Alliston, Ontario IIRC.
That's where all my relatives live, and where I lived last summer.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 21, 2005, 10:44:52 AM
Reading the comments about Acura/Honda vehicles reminded me of another, what I consider, a bonehead move.  In the Accord Hybrid, Honda decided a spare tire was un-necessary, so they give you a "flat tire repair kit".  This is fine if you only have a nail in the tire, but if you hit a pothole and split the sidewall, you're stuck until a wrecker comes along.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: VTEC_Inside on May 22, 2005, 12:07:20 AM
QuoteReading the comments about Acura/Honda vehicles reminded me of another, what I consider, a bonehead move.  In the Accord Hybrid, Honda decided a spare tire was un-necessary, so they give you a "flat tire repair kit".  This is fine if you only have a nail in the tire, but if you hit a pothole and split the sidewall, you're stuck until a wrecker comes along.
I see your point.

I think there are a few other cars though that have done away with the spare as well.

Didn't they do that on the C5? I seem to recall hearing about at least one other car that did the same.

Runflat or not, your cavernous pothole example would probably render the tire useless.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: BartsSVO on May 24, 2005, 07:20:42 AM
Yup, the C5 Corvette doesn't have a spare. However they use run flats from the factory.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: JWC on May 24, 2005, 05:48:20 PM
Add the Ford GT to the list of cars without a spare.


I was just reading the dealer handbook about the "emergency tire inflation kit".  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: Run Away on May 24, 2005, 06:44:38 PM
In all my time living in North America, I've never had a flat. My dad had one not long ago, but that's the only one I remember.  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: 280Z Turbo on May 24, 2005, 06:47:58 PM
I have a spare, but it takes up too much room and I don't take it with me. Of all the things that can go wrong with that car, a flat tire isn't likely to be one of them. :)
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: The Phantom on May 24, 2005, 07:43:55 PM
Quote
QuoteReading the comments about Acura/Honda vehicles reminded me of another, what I consider, a bonehead move.  In the Accord Hybrid, Honda decided a spare tire was un-necessary, so they give you a "flat tire repair kit".  This is fine if you only have a nail in the tire, but if you hit a pothole and split the sidewall, you're stuck until a wrecker comes along.
I see your point.

I think there are a few other cars though that have done away with the spare as well.

Didn't they do that on the C5? I seem to recall hearing about at least one other car that did the same.

Runflat or not, your cavernous pothole example would probably render the tire useless.
I think the C5 Z06 doesn't even get run flats!  They weigh too much and Chevy wanted to keep the weight down.

I read somewhere about one car that comes with a can of Fix-a-Flat.  I was thinking it was the Z06, but something told me it was a foreign jobber.  Perhaps the BMW M3 too?
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: The Phantom on May 24, 2005, 07:51:42 PM
I hit a big-ass pothole in LA a few months ago.  Upon closer inspection of the tire with which I hit the hole, I noticed a bulge in the sidewall.  I wasn't sure if the bulge was already there, but it's likely it was caused by the encounter with the pothole.

Flash to a couple weeks ago when I had my car on a lift to change the oil, and I noticed the front driver side tire has a flappy piece of rubber right at the edge of the tread going right down to the steel belting.  I now have two tires that have questionable life expectancy, so I'm getting a whole new set of BFG g-Force T/A KDWs.  They're one step up from what the car came with (KDWSs), which are actually really good tires themselves.  I can only imagine how good the KDWs will be.

I should be fine until I get the tires replaced.  Pray for me anyway.  :D
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: 280Z Turbo on May 24, 2005, 08:03:07 PM
I'm sure you'll be fine Troy although I'd get cheap tires if I had a GTO. :P  :lol:  B)  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: The Phantom on May 25, 2005, 09:44:50 AM
QuoteI'm sure you'll be fine Troy although I'd get cheap tires if I had a GTO. :P  :lol:  B)
Yeah, because even with Generals on it, the car would handle well.
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: 280Z Turbo on May 25, 2005, 01:13:22 PM
Quote
QuoteI'm sure you'll be fine Troy although I'd get cheap tires if I had a GTO. :P  :lol:  B)
Yeah, because even with Generals on it, the car would handle well.
Well, I just wouldn't want to be burning up expensive tires with that LS1. :lol:  
Title: The $250.00 air filter
Post by: VTEC_Inside on May 25, 2005, 02:34:58 PM
Quote
Quote
QuoteI'm sure you'll be fine Troy although I'd get cheap tires if I had a GTO. :P? :lol:? B)
Yeah, because even with Generals on it, the car would handle well.
Well, I just wouldn't want to be burning up expensive tires with that LS1. :lol:
:lol:  :lol: