Replacing the Accord - suggestions?

[MrH]

Are the seats height adjustable?

In the BRZ? Yes. Pretty sure they are in the GTI too, not positive though.

No adjustable lumbar support though.

[Laconian]

Well, the lumbar support in most cars is so shitty/misplaced that I don't even use it to begin with.

[2o6]

Not joking

[Eye of the Tiger]

Well, the lumbar support in most cars is so shitty/misplaced that I don't even use it to begin with.

Is it just me, or is the  "lumbar support" always way too high?

[Laconian]

Is it just me, or is the  "lumbar support" always way too high?

Yes

[hotrodalex]

In the BRZ? Yes. Pretty sure they are in the GTI too, not positive though.

No adjustable lumbar support though.

Is the BRZ any fun with an automatic?

I still say Challenger.

[Laconian]

I do like the Challenger, but there are no Challenging convertibles out there.

[Cookie Monster]

Driving a manual hurts your back?

Not calling you out or anything, just didn't associate the two causing problems...

Can you get a Jetta GLI with a DSG if you don't want another hatch? MrH is right, I think if I were going with an auto, I'd get a DSG and the VW is one of the few you can get a DSG with.

[Cookie Monster]

Also, way out there, but NC Miata? The 6 speed auto is supposedly excellent in that car (although miata.net is full of old people so I dunno how fun it really is), used ones with autos are much cheaper than manuals, and its reliable, good mpg and comes with nice creature comforts. Never had a problem with the seats either (though I have the base cloth seats, I don't know how the leather ones compare).

The low entry and exit may be a problem though, but you've already had an NA so maybe it'd work...

[CJ]

Not joking

That thing is a penalty box. 

[Laconian]

Driving a manual hurts your back?

Not calling you out or anything, just didn't associate the two causing problems...

Can you get a Jetta GLI with a DSG if you don't want another hatch? MrH is right, I think if I were going with an auto, I'd get a DSG and the VW is one of the few you can get a DSG with.

When my hamstrings are tight, using the clutch pulls my lower back.

[Laconian]

Also, way out there, but NC Miata? The 6 speed auto is supposedly excellent in that car (although miata.net is full of old people so I dunno how fun it really is), used ones with autos are much cheaper than manuals, and its reliable, good mpg and comes with nice creature comforts. Never had a problem with the seats either (though I have the base cloth seats, I don't know how the leather ones compare).

The low entry and exit may be a problem though, but you've already had an NA so maybe it'd work...

I haven't tried one in years. That might be a good idea.

[hotrodalex]

If it's too low, you can always fix it.

[TurboDan]

My initial thought after reading this was VW Eos.

[Rich]

My initial thought after reading this was VW Eos.

Power seats, DSG, hardtop vert (good for all the times you have to use it with the top up in Seattle).  Not sure if the seating position is too low, but it wouldn't hurt to try it out.

[Madman]

When my hamstrings are tight, using the clutch pulls my lower back.

You don't need a new car, you just need some good drugs! 

[CALL_911]

Honestly, i think the choice is clear. A GTI is the best fit for you. I think I've been in just about every car on the market for work, and the GTI is towards the top for my favorite seats. And the DSG is damn good. If I had to get an auto, I'd rather have that dsg than anything else. Maybe too similar having two hatches though?

Off the wall suggestion....BRZ! Great seats, great ammenities, great fun.

This man knows what he's talking about.

My mom has pretty bad back problems, she's actually commented on how my car's seats are the most comfortable she's used. Moreso than my dad's E60, my sister's TSX or her A4.

[cawimmer430]

Nobody has mentioned the most sensible and logical choice yet.

Let me be the one to do that. 

[nickdrinkwater]

Jag do Autos well and a 3 year old approved used XF would be in budget.

[Cookie Monster]

Power seats, DSG, hardtop vert (good for all the times you have to use it with the top up in Seattle).  Not sure if the seating position is too low, but it wouldn't hurt to try it out.

Seems like its just a more expensive, not as fun version of the Miata,which can also be had with a PRHT...

[MexicoCityM3]

Get rid of the TSX and get another manual car. Then there will be no conflict with your BF and you can avoid being an unthusiast. Comfort be damned.

[SVT666]

I second the EOS.  Despite the jumpy throttle tip-in, it's a nice car.  Not very sporty, but it's nice and very comfortable.

[MexicoCityM3]

I really hate the EOS with a passion. I?d rather have a Beetle convertible. That?s how much I hate the EOS right there!

[Rich]

Seems like its just a more expensive, not as fun version of the Miata,which can also be had with a PRHT...

Yeah that whole available with power seats, a DSG, and space behind the seat to move it around with legroom makes it just a worse imitation of a Miata.  Not to mention the seating position is higher (easier ingress/egress)

I know it's not as fun, but for someone with back problems I can see it being a whole lot easier to live with. 

And more enjoyable than having a second hatch/wagon thing in the household.

[MrH]

Seems like its just a more expensive, not as fun version of the Miata,which can also be had with a PRHT...

Except the Miata's seats are horrible, it's cramped, and reaaaaally low to the ground.  For a bad back, I don't know if I can think of a worse car.

And for all you people saying the lumbar support is too high?!  They've all been too low for me.  What cars are you driving?

[Rich]

Except the Miata's seats are horrible, it's cramped, and reaaaaally low to the ground.  For a bad back, I don't know if I can think of a worse car.

And for all you people saying the lumbar support is too high?!  They've all been too low for me.  What cars are you driving?

You have a long torso too

[nickdrinkwater]

Eos is a v nice car for the fun option n can be frugal too

[Eye of the Tiger]

I drove a 2000 Cadillac Sedan Deville today, and I just have to recommend it. Very classy.

[Laconian]

I drove a 2000 Cadillac Sedan Deville today, and I just have to recommend it. Very classy.

I hope for your sake that the paint was pearlescent.

[Eye of the Tiger]

I hope for your sake that the paint was pearlescent.

Pearlescent crystal white cloud, I believe.