In a candy shell ...

[Lebowski]

Halloween candy made me think of it. I've always really liked Reese's pieces but almost never see them.

[Laconian]

Both of them are bad IMO. M&Ms are flavorless. Reese's Pieces are greese'y.

[Lebowski]

Both of them are bad IMO. M&Ms are flavorless. Reese's Pieces are greese'y.

Unamerican!   

[Laconian]

<-- Healthy BMI!

[Eye of the Tiger]

Mix them together and make coooooookies.

[Cookie Monster]

Since you said original M&M's I went with Reese's Pieces.

I only like the crispy and pretzel M&M's.

[Eye of the Tiger]

Since you said original M&M's I went with Reese's Pieces.

I only like the crispy and pretzel M&M's.

wtf is wrong with you man

[Cookie Monster]

wtf is wrong with you man

Wat.

[Eye of the Tiger]

Wat.

If any M&M is better than the originals, it's the peanut. All other M&M flavors are crap.

[Laconian]

The peanut butter M&Ms are a better way to get good fatty PB flavour than Reese's.

[Lebowski]

The pb M&Ms are pretty good, but I think Reese's are better.

[Raza]

Reese's Pieces are the shiznite. Awesome stuff.

[12,000 RPM]

The peanut butter M&Ms are a better way to get good fatty PB flavour than Reese's.

O wait Reeses pieces are the fake peanut buttern M&Ms right

Yea PB M&Ms get my vote for president.

[2o6]

Reeses Pieces don't have chocolate; PB M&M's do

[veeman]

E.T. made Reeses Pieces.

They have a sweet aftertaste I'm not a huge fan of.  Peanut M&Ms all the way.

[Eye of the Tiger]

Good enough for E.T., good enough for me.
PB M&Ms make me say ouuuuchh....

[Cookie Monster]

You guise aren't getting the point of the poll. It's normal brown wrapper M&M's vs Reese's Pieces. Any of the other kinds of M&M's would kick Reese's Pieces butt.

[giant_mtb]

Reeses Pieces over original M&Ms.

Peanut butter m&ms win all, though.

[Lebowski]

You guise aren't getting the point of the poll. It's normal brown wrapper M&M's vs Reese's Pieces. Any of the other kinds of M&M's would kick Reese's Pieces butt.

I'm pretty sure the original is by far the most popular.

Regardless, I wanted to make it straightforward Pieces vs M&Ms. As opposed to Pieces vs your individual choice of favorite M&Ms.

[Laconian]

WHY are they so popular, though? It's like eating chalk.

[Lebowski]

WHY are they so popular, though? It's like eating chalk.

I don't think they're bad, but that was sorta my point.  I think most people if asked would say Pieces are better, yet M&Ms seem to be 20x more popular.

You don't like either though, so you don't count. 

[12,000 RPM]

People in general have shit taste. Take ranch dressing for example.

[Cookie Monster]

I'm pretty sure the original is by far the most popular.

Regardless, I wanted to make it straightforward Pieces vs M&Ms. As opposed to Pieces vs your individual choice of favorite M&Ms.

The brown ones are just the most common ones, not the best. A lot of stores don't even carry any M&M's other than the normal and the peanut ones.

[shp4man]

Holy shit, too many carbs. Refined sugar isn't healthy.

[Lebowski]

The brown ones are just the most common ones, not the best. A lot of stores don't even carry any M&M's other than the normal and the peanut ones.

Apparently someone thinks they're the best.

[Cookie Monster]

Holy shit, too many carbs. Refined sugar isn't healthy.

Imma eat two pax of them tonight. Come at me bro.

Apparently someone thinks they're the best.

Well the ones I see most commonly at the stores are the regular, peanut, peanut butter, crispy and pretzel. People with peanut allergies can't even have two of those, and I guess weird people don't like the crispy or pretzel ones so I can see how the regulars would be popular.

[Eye of the Tiger]

Holy shit, too many carbs. Refined sugar isn't healthy.

YEAH. It's a better treat to eat a slab of bacon.

[Xer0]

There are almond M&Ms every now and then too which tock


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JWC]

Between the two listed, plain M&Ms. I never liked Reese's Pieces---they really have little flavor and what they do have is similar to something by Weyerhaeuser, not Mars.

[Raza]

You guise aren't getting the point of the poll. It's normal brown wrapper M&M's vs Reese's Pieces. Any of the other kinds of M&M's would kick Reese's Pieces butt.

Unfortunately, no.  All M&Ms are inferior to Reese's Pieces.  Some less so, like peanut, crispy, pretzel, and coconut, but Reese's Pieces are THE BEST candy shell candy.  Don't even get me started on the joke that is Peanut Butter M&Ms.....might as well throw that in the pile with Hydrox.